With all the holidays and time off, it's been a while since I've been into Natal. The biggest news to write on is of course Gilad Shalit. Last week, the state of Israel rejoiced at the return of Gilad Shalit, an Israeli soldier held captive by Hamas for the past 5 years. I remember when Gilad was captured; I was 18, Gilad only a year older. Hamas refused to allow the Red Cross access to Shalit and only released 3 letters, a tape, and a video him during his capture. I can't even begin to imagine how his family felt, let alone the terror Gilad faced. Shalit's capture and subsequent demand for prisoner release from Hamas has become one of the faces of the Gaza conflict.
For many in Israel and the world, October 18th was spent glued to the television, watching multiple news channels hoping for new coverage. The whole state was buzzing. I awoke to helicopters flying around and everywhere, people were talking. Each kiosk had a news station on and all conversations were turned towards Shalit. Haaretz reported that 70% of country tuned in to reports on Shalit. Though I was at work, I kept refreshing CNN and Haaretz every few minutes, not wanting to miss a second. I, along with countless others, was overcome with emotion at the first pictures released of Gilad, his interview with Egyptian television, and the first moments of father and son reunited.
However, his release is not without controversy. In exchange for Shalit, Prime Minister Netanyahu agreed to release over 1,000 Palestinians from Israeli jail, with 280 serving multiple life sentences for planning and executing terror attacks. While many in Israel supported the prisoner exchange, there are also many who see it as a victory for Hamas and terrorists. The deal has raised a lot of tough questions. Firstly, is one soldier worth the price of 1,027 prisoners responsible for the deaths of almost 600 Israeli's? More importantly, will this deal lead to more kidnappings and more prisoner exchanges? If yes, will Israel go along with Hamas and continue to release prisoners in exchange for soldiers? What other implications does that have for the ongoing conflict? The deal also highlights the divide between Hamas and Palestinian President Abbas, their supporters, and the amount of power each hold.
I personally struggle with all these questions. While I was happy to see Gilad alive and back home with his family, I couldn't help but wonder at what price. How many more families will have to go through the pain of having a loved one kidnapped and held hostage? Will the released prisoners go on to commit more terror attacks? I read an article about Wafa al-Biss, a released female prisoner who was caught before detonating a suicide bomb, giving a speech to children the day after her release. She was encouraging them to strive for martyrdom and fight the "Zionist arrogance in the land of Palestine". It's hard to maintain that happiness when I know that the released prisoners are gearing up to attack Israel again.
Anshel Pfeffer for Haaretz writes, "In the end Hamas got its 1,000 prisoners, the Egyptians reaped the PR dividends, and Israelis were left with the bittersweet and voyeuristic pleasure of participating in the Shalit family reunion." One can see it as a victory for Israel and those who've lost loved ones and at the same time it can be a victory for Hamas and their so-called martyrs. I think it's hard to say that there is a right side and a wrong side and for now I can only hope that no more families have to go through what Shalit's did and be thankful that he has returned home.